# Europakommissionens beslut den 1 september 1993 i målet VELLA mot Förenade kungariket (nr 20482/92)

- Rubrik i HUDOC: VELLA v. THE UNITED KINGDOM
- Slag: Europakommissionens beslut · språk: engelska · datum: 1993-09-01
- Ansökningsnummer: 20482/92
- ECLI: ECLI:CE:ECHR:1993:0901DEC002048292
- Artiklar (HUDOC): 8, 8-1, 13, 14
- Slutsats (HUDOC): Inadmissible
- Källa: Europadomstolen (HUDOC), © ECHR-CEDH: https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-1663
- Ratio Lex: https://ratiolex.se/internationell-ratt/europadomstolen/001-1663/

Elektronisk version. Den undertecknade texten i domstolens arkiv är den autentiska (art. 44.3 EKMR).

## AS TO THE ADMISSIBILITY OF

Application No. 20482/92  
by Natalino and Claire VELLA  
against the United Kingdom

The European Commission of Human Rights (First Chamber) sitting  
in private on 1 September 1993, the following members being present:

MM.   A. WEITZEL, President  
C.L. ROZAKIS  
F. ERMACORA  
E. BUSUTTIL  
Mrs.  J. LIDDY  
MM.   M.P. PELLONPÄÄ  
G.B. REFFI  
N. BRATZA

Mrs.  M.F. BUQUICCHIO, Secretary to the Chamber

Having regard to Article 25 of the Convention for the Protection  
of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms;

Having regard to the application introduced on 3 July 1992 by  
Natalino and Claire Vella against the United Kingdom and registered on  
12 August 1993 under file No. 20482/92;

Having regard to the report provided for in Rule 47 of the Rules  
of Procedure of the Commission;

Having deliberated;

Decides as follows:

## THE FACTS

The first applicant is an Irish citizen born in 1953 and  
currently serving a prison sentence in Frankland Prison, England.

The second applicant is the wife of the first applicant.  She was  
born in 1953 and currently resides in Dublin.

The applicants are represented by Peter Madden, a solicitor  
practising in Belfast.

The facts of the present case,as submitted by the applicants, may  
be summarised as follows:

The first and second applicants were married on 31 August 1974  
in Dublin.  They have two children.

The first applicant was arrested on 18 June 1984 in England and  
sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment on charges of possession of  
explosives and firearms.  He has been classified as a category A  
prisoner.

The first applicant, at the time of his arrest, had been married  
for 10 years and had no family connections in England.  He was born in  
Dublin and comes from a tightly knit community in Dublin.

The first applicant has made repeated transfer petitions to the  
Home Office requesting to serve his prison sentence in Northern Ireland  
in order to be nearer to the second applicant and their children.  The  
petitions have consistently been refused.  According to the Minister's  
answer of 21 January 1991, "the Secretary of State has fully considered  
... the petition but is not prepared to grant (the applicant's) request  
for a transfer to Northern Ireland because (the applicant) was  
domiciled in the Republic of Ireland prior to ... conviction".

The second applicant is in part-time employment and earns  
approximately £60 (Irish) per week.  She receives no State assistance  
for prison visits to England to see the first applicant.  She is unable  
to visit the first applicant due to financial strain and ill health.  
Her health has deteriorated in the past two years and the average cost  
of £400  per visit is too expensive.  Moreover the trip to see the  
first applicant was dominated by fear and anxiety due to possible acts  
by the security forces acting under the Prevention of Terrorism Act.  
Her last visit to the first applicant was in November 1990.  Before  
this time,  she was able to visit the first applicant two or three  
times a year.

The applicants have continued to maintain family links by way of  
correspondence and telephone calls.

The first applicant submits that the conditions of detention for  
Irish Republican prisoners in England are considerably worse than those  
for their counterparts in Northern Ireland.  Unlike the position in  
Northern Ireland, the applicant and other Irish Republican prisoners  
are completely segregated from each other unless one or two prisoners  
are in the same establishment due to the fact that there are no other  
prisons available.  Irish Republican prisoners are generally held in  
solitary confinement, in isolation, and dispersed throughout as many  
available prison establishments as are in existence throughout England.  
There is a policy of regular transfer from prison to prison, resulting  
in the prisoners being unable to settle into familiar surroundings,  
which has an adverse effect on health for prisoners serving lengthy  
prison sentences.  So far the first applicant has been transferred  
19 times to different prisons in England.

## RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW AND PRACTICE

a) Visit entitlement

The Prison Rules 1964 (S.I. 1964/388), made by statutory  
instrument under the Prison Act 1952, Sections 47 and 52, contain,  
inter alia, the following provisions:

"31.(1) Special attention shall be paid to the maintenance of  
such relations between a prisoner and his family as are desirable  
in the best interests of both.

(2) A prisoner shall be encouraged and assisted to establish and  
maintain such relations with persons and agencies outside prison  
as may, in the opinion of the governor, best promote the  
interests of his family and his own social rehabilitation...

34(1) An unconvicted prisoner may ... receive as many visits as  
he wishes within such limits and subject to such conditions as  
the Secretary of State may direct, either generally or in a  
particular case.

(2) A convicted prisoner shall be entitled -  
...(b) To receive a visit once in four weeks ..."

From April 1992, the normal visit entitlement was increased to  
two visits in every period of four weeks.

Accumulated Visits (Standing Order):

"Subject to the provisions of Orders 5A 12-18 ... convicted  
inmates may be allowed to accumulate visits up to a maximum  
of 12 and apply ... to be temporarily transferred to any  
local prison to take their visits.  Category A inmates ...  
must petition for temporary transfer ... An inmate must  
have accumulated at least 3 visits before he can be  
transferred to take accumulated visits."

b) Temporary transfer

The Criminal Justice Act 1961 and Standing Order 5A provide that  
a prisoner may apply for temporary transfer to another prison to  
receive visits.  These may be from a close relative or relatives who  
may also be in custody.  "Close relative" is defined so as to include  
"wife".  The material provision is Section 27(1) of the Criminal  
Justice Act 1961 which provides that:

"The responsible minister may, on the application of a  
person serving a sentence of imprisonment or detention in  
any part of the United Kingdom, make an order for his  
temporary transfer to another part of the United Kingdom...  
and for his removal to an appropriate institution there."

c) Permanent transfer

Section 26 of the Criminal Justice Act 1961 provides inter alia:

"(1)  The responsible Minister may, on the application of  
a person serving a sentence of imprisonment or detention in  
any part of the United Kingdom, make an order for his  
transfer to another part of the United Kingdom, there to  
serve the remainder of his sentence, and for his removal to  
an appropriate institution [there]...

(4)  Subject to the following provisions of this section, a  
person transferred under this section to any part of the United  
Kingdom there to serve his sentence or the remainder of his  
sentence shall be treated for purposes of detention, release,  
supervision, recall and otherwise as if that sentence (and any  
other sentence to which he may be subject) had been an equivalent  
sentence passed by a court in the place to which he is  
transferred."

In a written decision relating to a request by a prisoner for  
permanent transfer from the United Kingdom to Northern Ireland the  
Secretary of State indicated the criteria he would apply in exercising  
his discretion to transfer prisoners.  That decision reads, in part,  
as follows:

"Revised criteria governing the transfer of prisoners to  
another jurisdiction in the United Kingdom were announced  
in reply to a Parliamentary question on 23 June 1989.  
These provide that an inmate's request to be transferred  
will, normally, be granted provided that all the following  
conditions are met:

(i)  the inmate would have at least six months left to  
serve in the receiving jurisdiction before his or her date  
of release;

(ii)  the inmate was ordinarily resident in the receiving  
jurisdiction prior to the current sentence or his or her  
close family currently reside there and there are  
reasonable grounds for believing that it is the inmate's  
firm intention to take up residence there on release;  and

(iii) both departments concerned are reasonably satisfied  
that the inmate will not, if transferred, disrupt or  
attempt to disrupt any prison establishment or otherwise  
pose an unacceptable risk to security.

It was also stated, however, that even if these criteria  
were met, transfer may be refused if it is considered that  
the inmate's crimes were so serious as to render him or her  
undeserving of any degree of public sympathy or to make it  
inappropriate that the inmate should benefit from a  
substantial reduction in the time left to serve if that  
would be a consequence of transfer.

Similarly, transfers may be refused if there are reasonable  
grounds for believing that the inmate's primary intention  
in making the application is to secure a reduction in the  
time left to serve.  On the other hand, an application that  
does not meet these conditions may, nevertheless, be  
granted where there are strong compassionate or other  
compelling grounds for transfer".

d) Differences in release policies and procedures

The law and practice relating to the proportion of a sentence  
which must be served before release differs between the three United  
Kingdom jurisdictions.  Prisoners serving determinate sentences in  
England and Wales are entitled to one-third remission of their  
sentence.  Prisoners in Northern Ireland are generally entitled to  
remission of one half of their sentence.  There are also differences  
in the administration of life sentences so that those serving sentences  
for comparable offences are generally released earlier in Northern  
Ireland than they would be if they were sentenced in England and Wales.

e) Categorisation of prisoners

Category A prisoners are defined as those whose escape would be  
highly dangerous to the public, or to the police, or to the security  
of the State, no matter how unlikely that escape might be.  Category  
A prisoners are further classified as presenting either a standard,  
high, or an exceptional escape risk.  Prisoners assessed as Category  
A (Exceptional Risk) are located in Special Security Units within  
prisons.  In deciding on a prisoner's categorisation, account is taken  
of the nature and circumstances of the offence, details of any previous  
convictions, where appropriate, the prisoner's mental state, and  
reports from police, prison and other sources.  The need to continue  
to hold a confirmed Category A inmate in the highest security category  
is reviewed at least once every 12 months on the basis of up to date  
reports.

Category A prisoners are subject to certain restrictions.  Their  
movements within the prison are escorted and are closely monitored and  
recorded.  Their visitors have to be approved and their photographs  
verified by the police under special arrangements known as the Approved  
Visitors Scheme.  They are subject to frequent cell changes.  They are  
not permitted to work in the prison kitchen.  In addition, prisoners  
in Special Security Units do not have access to prison workshops.

## COMPLAINTS

The applicants complain that the refusal of a transfer is in  
violation of their right to respect for their private and family life  
as guaranteed by Article 8 of the Convention.  They submit that  
alternative prison accommodation is available in Northern Ireland and  
that there is no valid reason for refusing the transfer.  The denial  
of a transfer is deliberately and unnecessarily punitive.

The applicants also complain that they are discriminated against  
on the grounds of political or other opinion, national origin and  
association with a national minority, contrary to Article 14 of the  
Convention.  In particular, they submit that Irish Republican prisoners  
are discriminated against as a class in that they are treated less  
favourably than other prisoners in relation to questions of transfer.

The applicants further submit that they have no effective remedy  
as required by Article 13 of the Convention.

## THE LAW

**1.** The applicants complain that the refusal to transfer the first  
applicant permanently to a prison in Northern Ireland to facilitate  
visits from his family is a violation of Article 8 (Art. 8) of the  
Convention.

Article 8 (Art. 8) of the Convention provides as follows:

"1.  Everyone has the right to respect for his private and  
family life, his home and his correspondence.

**2.** There shall be no interference by a public authority  
with the exercise of this right except such as in  
accordance with the law and is necessary in a democratic  
society in the interests of national security, public  
safety or the economic well-being of the country, for the  
prevention of disorder or crime, for the protection of  
health or morals, or for the protection of the rights and  
freedoms of others."

The Commission has considered whether the relationship between  
the applicants constitutes family life within the meaning of Article 8  
(Art. 8) of the Convention.  It notes that the applicants are husband  
and wife.  It recalls that it has held that in the context of prisoners  
or other persons who are detained the concept of "family life" must be  
given a wider scope than in other situations:  "Prisoners generally  
have limited means of contact with the outside community and of  
maintaining relationships with family members.  'Family life' for  
prisoners is inevitably restricted to visits, correspondence and  
possibly other forms of communication such as telephone calls.  
Emotional dependency between, for example, parents and adult children,  
or siblings is even enhanced in these circumstances.  The Commission  
recalls in this context that the European Prison Rules emphasise the  
need to encourage these links:

'65. Every effort shall be made to ensure that the regimes of  
the institutions are designed and managed so as:

(c)  to sustain and strengthen those links with relatives and  
the outside community that will promote the best interests of  
prisoners and their families.'"

(No. 19085/91, Dec. 9.12.92, to be published in D.R.).

The Commission has also stated the opinion that Article 8  
(Art. 8) requires the State to assist prisoners as far as possible to  
create and sustain ties with people outside prison in order to  
facilitate prisoners' social rehabilitation (e.g. No. 9054/80, Dec.  
8.10.82, D.R. 30 p. 113, and No. 15817/89, Dec. 1.10.90, to be  
published in D.R.).

In light of these factors, the Commission finds that the  
applicants' complaint must be held as falling within the scope of  
Article 8 para. 1 (Art. 8-1) of the Convention.

The applicants have submitted that the refusal of a permanent  
transfer constitutes an interference with their right to respect for  
their family life.  The Commission considers, however, that the  
applicants are arguing in effect not that the State should refrain from  
acting but rather that it should take steps to implement a particular  
policy.  Although the essential object of Article 8 (Art. 8) is to  
protect the individual against arbitrary interference by public  
authorities, there may be positive obligations inherent in an effective  
"respect" for family life (see e.g. Eur. Court H.R., Marckx judgment  
of 13 June 1979, Series A no. 31, p. 14 para. 31).  In this context,  
the notion of "respect" is not clear-cut and its requirements will vary  
considerably from case to case according to the practices followed and  
the situations obtaining in Contracting States.  In determining whether  
or not such an obligation exists, regard must be had to the fair  
balance which has to be struck between the general interest and the  
interests of the individual (see e.g. Eur. Court H. R., Abdulaziz,  
Cabales and Balkandali judgment of 28 May 1985, Series A no. 94, p. 33  
para. 67, and the B. v. France judgment of 25 March 1992, to be  
published in Series A no. 232-C, para. 44).

The Commission recalls that in the present case the first  
applicant, who is from the Republic of Ireland, is detained in a prison  
in England and that he has requested a transfer to facilitate visits  
from his family, including the second applicant.  The Commission notes  
that the first applicant is serving a long term of imprisonment and  
that the considerable distance involved imposes difficulties in  
utilising visit entitlements which cannot be said to be negligible.

The Commission notes, however, that the first applicant is  
lawfully detained for serious offences committed against the background  
of a terrorist campaign.  Any transfer would be arguably highly  
dangerous, increasing greatly the risk of escape.

The Commission also refers to its constant case-law according to  
which a prisoner has no right as such under the Convention to choose  
the place of his confinement and that a separation of a detained person  
from his family and the hardship resulting from it are the inevitable  
consequences of detention (see e.g. No. 5229/71, Dec. 5.10.72,  
Collection 42 p. 14, and No. 5712/72, Dec. 18.7.74, Collection 46 p.  
112).  The Commission considers that only in exceptional circumstances  
will the detention of a prisoner a long way from his home or family  
infringe the requirements of Article 8 (Art. 8) of the Convention (see  
e.g. No. 5712/72, Dec. 18.7.74 loc. cit., and No. 7819/77, Dec. 6.5.78,  
published in part, D.R. 14, p. 186).

The Commission finds that no exceptional circumstances arise in  
this case.  It notes that the first applicant is detained in England  
since he was arrested and tried there in respect of offences committed  
as part of an alleged terrorist campaign in England.  As a prisoner,  
the applicant is subject to the normal regime applicable to his  
category as regards correspondence and visits.   The second applicant  
is entitled to visit the first applicant.  Before 1990 she visited him  
two or three times a year.

Having regard to the above circumstances, the Commission finds  
that the decision of the United Kingdom Government to refuse permanent  
transfer arrangements to Northern Ireland discloses no lack of respect  
for the applicants' family life within the meaning of Article 8  
(Art. 8) of the Convention.

It follows that the complaint is manifestly ill-founded within  
the meaning of Article 27 para. 2 (Art. 27-2) of the Convention.

2.    The applicants also complain that they are discriminated against,  
contrary to Article 14 in conjunction with Article 8 (Art. 14+8) of the

Convention, since Irish Republican prisoners in the United Kingdom are  
treated less favourably than other prisoners as regards transfer.

Article 14 (Art. 14) of the Convention provides as follows:

"The enjoyment of the rights and freedoms set forth in this  
Convention shall be secured without discrimination on any ground  
such as sex, race, colour, language, religion, political or other  
opinion, national or social origin, association with a national  
minority, property, birth or other status."

The Commission notes that the applicants do not contend that  
there is a blanket prohibition on transfer of Irish Republican  
prisoners to Northern Ireland.  In the present case, the Commission  
recalls that the first applicant was refused a transfer.  This refusal  
must be seen in the context of the first applicant's status as an Irish  
Republican prisoner, with the security implications of such status.  
The Commission considers that different considerations concerning  
security may apply to different prisoners.  It recalls that the first  
applicant is a Category A (high security or exceptional risk) prisoner  
convicted in relation to terrorist offences. In these circumstances,  
his position cannot be considered as analogous to that of other  
prisoners for the purposes of Article 14 (Art. 14) of the Convention.

It follows that this complaint is manifestly ill-founded within  
the meaning of Article 27 para. 2 (Art. 27-2) of the Convention.

**3.** The applicants also complain under Article 13 (Art. 13) of the  
Convention that they have no effective remedy in respect of their  
complaints.

Article 13 (Art. 13), however, does not require a remedy under  
domestic law in respect of any alleged violation of the Convention.  
It only applies if the individual can be said to have an "arguable  
claim" of a violation of the Convention (Eur. Court H.R., Boyle and  
Rice judgment of 27 April 1988, Series A no. 131, p. 23 para. 52).

The Commission recalls that it has rejected the applicants'  
complaints under Articles 8 and 14 (Art. 8, 14) of the Convention, no  
lack of respect for family life or unlawful discrimination having been  
disclosed.  In these circumstances, the Commission also finds that the  
applicants cannot be said to have an "arguable claim" of a violation  
of the Convention necessitating an Article 13 (Art. 13) remedy.

It follows that this part of the application must also be  
rejected as being manifestly ill-founded within the meaning of Article  
27 para. 2 (Art. 27-2) of the Convention.

## For these reasons, the Commission by a majority

## DECLARES THE APPLICATION INADMISSIBLE.

Secretary to the First Chamber        President of the First Chamber

## (M. F. BUQUICCHIO)                        (A. WEITZEL)

