# Europakommissionens beslut den 7 april 1967 i målet X. mot Tyskland (nr 2472/65)

- Rubrik i HUDOC: X. v. THE FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF GERMANY
- Slag: Europakommissionens beslut · språk: engelska · datum: 1967-04-07
- Ansökningsnummer: 2472/65
- ECLI: ECLI:CE:ECHR:1967:0407DEC000247265
- Artiklar (HUDOC): 6, 6-1, 14, 16, 35, 35-1, P1-1, 5, 5-1
- Slutsats (HUDOC): Inadmissible
- Källa: Europadomstolen (HUDOC), © ECHR-CEDH: https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-3003
- Ratio Lex: https://ratiolex.se/internationell-ratt/europadomstolen/001-3003/

Elektronisk version. Den undertecknade texten i domstolens arkiv är den autentiska (art. 44.3 EKMR).

## THE FACTS

Whereas the facts presented by the Applicant may be summarised as  
follows:

The Applicant is an American citizen, born in 1922 in Germany. He is  
a management consultant by profession and at present residing at  
Farmington, Michigan, USA.

On 20th May, 1963, he lodged an Application (No. 1908/63) with the  
Commission which was declared inadmissible on 8th July, 1964, for  
non-exhaustion of domestic remedies, all proceedings in which the  
Applicant was involved, at that time still pending before the German  
courts. He now presents his case again as follows:

I. He states that in 1959 he took up employment under a two-year  
contract with the Volkswagenwerke A.G. at a monthly salary of 4,000 DM.  
Due to differences of opinion as to certain management problems, it was  
decided that the Applicant's employment should be discontinued. It was  
further agreed in writing that he should be fully remunerated for the  
remainder of the two-year period.

As the Company allegedly failed to honour this agreement and as other  
disputes arose, the Applicant filed in November, 1960, a suit before  
the Labour Court (Arbeitsgericht) of Braunschweig claiming damages of  
70,000 DM. The case is still pending and, according to the Applicant,  
a hearing of the Parties has not been fixed in 4 1/2 years.

II. (1) In December, 1960, the Applicant was arrested but immediately  
released on bail of 10,000 DM. On his arrest all his papers were seized  
although no valid search warrant had been issued. These papers were  
subsequently turned over to the Volkswagenwerke for inspection.

In April, 1962 he moved to Innsbruck.

It appears that on .. June,. 1962, he was convicted by the Regional  
Court (Landgericht) at Hildesheim on charges of fraud and making false  
statements and sentenced to one year's imprisonment. The above bail was  
declared forfeit as security for costs.

(2) On .. October, 1962, the Applicant was arrested in Austria, his  
extradition to Germany having been requested by the German authorities  
in pursuance of an order of the local judge at Wolfsburg, dated ..  
October, 1962.

(3) It appears that the Applicant had lodged an appeal (Revision) with  
the Federal Court (Bundesgerichtshof) with regard to his conviction on  
the charge of fraud, but had failed to appeal against his conviction  
for making false statements.

On January, 1963, the Federal Court quashed the conviction for fraud  
and ordered a new hearing before the Regional Court at Braunschweig.

(4) On .. February, 1963, the Applicant was extradited from Austria to  
Germany where, without having ever been heard by a judge, he was  
suddenly released on .. March, 1963. He was then informed that a  
deportation order would be issued to bar permanently his entry into  
Germany, but that the Public Prosecutor would discontinue the criminal  
proceedings against him on condition that he did not pursue his claims  
against the Volkswagenwerke. This he refused to do.

After his release on .. March, 1963, the Applicant returned to  
Innsbruck and, on .. May, 1963, the Mayor (Regierungspräsident) of  
Lüneburg (Germany) issued a deportation order against him in his  
absence.

(5) On .. October, 1963, the Regional Court at Braunschweig heard the  
case referred to it by the Federal Court and convicted the Applicant  
on the charge of fraud, presumably in his absence. On the same day the  
Regional Court gave a decision declaring the bail of 10,000 DM forfeit,  
allegedly without having issued an order of forfeiture and without  
having given the Applicant an opportunity to be heard, and although the  
local judge at Wolfsburg, in 1962, had allegedly ordered the bail to  
be returned to him.

(6) It appears that the Applicant lodged an appeal (Revision) against  
his conviction of .. October, 1963 with the Federal Court and another  
appeal (Beschwerde) against the order of forfeiture of the bail with  
the Court of Appeal at Celle.

The latter appeal was dismissed by the Court of Appeal on .. January,  
1964, and a constitutional appeal (Verfassungsbeschwerde) lodged  
against this decision with the Federal Constitutional Court  
(Bundesverfassungsgericht) was rejected on .. February, 1965, as being  
clearly ill-founded.

By decision of .. November, 1964, the Federal Court, however, again  
quashed his conviction for fraud and decided that no further  
proceedings should be taken on this count.

(7) The Applicant states that he also lodged an application for retrial  
concerning his conviction for making false statements and that this was  
dismissed by the Court of Appeal of Celle on .. August, 1965.

(8) In September, 1963, the Applicant had unsuccessfully requested that  
criminal proceedings should be instituted against the above judge at  
Wolfsburg, another judge, the Public Prosecutor and six witnesses.

(9) The Applicant ascribes the actions taken against him to the  
influence of Volkswagenwerke then owned by the Government, and of the  
local judge at Wolfsburg, a former SS officer. The same intrigues  
caused his dismissal from employment by another management consultant  
at Siegburg. In September, 1961, he instituted legal proceedings  
against this second employer before the Labour Court in Cologne, but  
he does not indicate what decision was given by this court.

The Applicant alleges that, as a result of his illegal and unfounded  
prosecutions, he lost his property and employment and suffered injuries  
to his health;  that since his arrest his case against the  
Volkswagenwerke has been deliberately sabotaged;  that his deportation  
prevents him from visiting his parents living in Germany and caused the  
breakdown of his marriage.

III. Consequently, it appears that the Applicant was finally convicted  
only in respect of the charge of making false statements. This  
conviction was pronounced by the Regional Court of Hildesheim on ..  
June, 1962 and the Applicant did not appeal against it. In respect of  
the charges of fraud, his conviction was finally quashed by the Federal  
Court on .. November, 1964. It seems, therefore, that the Applicant's  
complaints concern primarily his final conviction in 1962 with regard  
to making false statements but that he also considers the subsequent  
proceedings to be objectionable.

IV. The Applicant's complaints may be set out as follows:

(1) In December, 1960 his papers were seized without a valid search  
warrant and only a part of these papers were returned to him so far;

(2) Prior to and during the trial in 1962, the Public Prosecutor gave  
false and misleading statements to the Press which contributed to  
destroying whatever chances he might have had for future employment in  
Germany;

(3) His conviction and sentence as well as the court proceedings  
concerned were unlawful. In this respect it appears that he complains  
not only of his conviction for making false statements in June, 1962,  
but also of his subsequent conviction for fraud which was quashed by  
the Federal Court. He alleges in particular:

(a) that he was wrongly convicted;

(b) that the court proceedings in June, 1962 were unlawful in that:

(aa) new facts were introduced by the prosecution so late that he had  
no possibility of preparing his defence;  
(bb) he was called a gangster before and during the trial;  
(cc) that he was not allowed any assistance by counsel;

(c) that in the 1962 proceedings and the subsequent proceedings the  
courts had refused to hear witnesses and check documents attesting to  
his innocence;

(4) The refusal of a retrial with respect to his conviction for making  
false statements was unlawful;

(5) The Convention had been violated in that:

(a) his arrest in Austria on .. October, 1962 leading to his  
extradition to Germany was unlawful, and  
(b) there was no danger of flight which could have justified his  
detention pending extradition in Austria from .. October, 1962 to ..  
February, 1963;

(6) Subsequent to his extradition the German authorities had violated  
the Convention in that:

(a) he was unlawfully detained in prison in Germany from .. February,  
1963 to .. March, 1963 and was neither heard by a judge during that  
period nor informed of the reasons for his detention;  
(b) there was no danger of flight justifying his detention in Germany  
from .. February to .. March, 1963;

(7) During his detention

(a) the prison authorities refused to give him writing materials and  
the mail from his lawyer and the American Consulate was held back (it  
is not clear whether this allegation concerns his detention in Austria  
or in Germany);  
(b) he was subjected to degrading and inhuman treatment in that the  
prison authorities refused him medical treatment, he had to sleep on  
the floor for several weeks, and was occasionally locked in a cold cell  
(it is not clear whether this allegation concerns his detention in  
Austria or in Germany);

(8) He was deprived of his possessions in that the bail was declared  
forfeit and moreover the decision of .. October, 1963 by which the bail  
was declared forfeit was unlawful and that there was no hearing and no  
court decision published in this regard;

(9) The German authorities discriminated against him by reason of his  
anti-Nazi opinions.

V. The Applicant alleges a violation of Articles 3, 5, 6, 8, 13, 14 and  
16 of the Convention as well as Article 1 of the Protocol to the  
Convention. He also claims damages of 613,000 DM.

## THE LAW

Whereas, in regard to the Applicant's complaints that his papers were  
seized in 1960 (see IV, (1) of the Facts) and that the Public  
Prosecutor made statements to the press prior to and during the trial  
in June, 1962 (see IV, (2) of the Facts), it is to be observed that,  
under Article 26 (Art. 26) of the Convention, the Commission may only  
deal with a matter after all domestic remedies have been exhausted  
according to the generally recognised rules of international law;  and  
whereas the Applicant failed to show that he has raised these points  
with any German court; whereas, therefore, he has not exhausted the  
remedies available to him under German law; whereas, moreover, an  
examination of the case as it has been submitted, including an  
examination made ex officio, does not disclose the existence of any  
special circumstances which might have absolved the Applicant,  
according to the generally recognised rules of international law, from  
exhausting the domestic remedies at his disposal; whereas, therefore,  
the condition as to the exhaustion of domestic remedies laid down in  
Articles 26 and 27, paragraph (3) (Art. 26, 27-3), of the Convention  
has not been complied with by the Applicant;

Whereas the Applicant apparently complains of his conviction and  
sentence by the Hildesheim Regional Court on .. June, 1962, on charges  
of making false statements and of fraud;

Whereas, first in regard to his complaints relating to his conviction  
and sentence for making false statements and the court proceedings  
relating to this charge, the Applicant failed to appeal from the  
decision of the Regional Court at Hildesheim, dated .. June, 1962;  
whereas, therefore, he has again not exhausted the remedies available  
to him under German law, and no special circumstance is to him under  
German law, and no special circumstance is disclosed which might have  
absolved him from exhausting such remedies; whereas, therefore, the  
condition as to the exhaustion of domestic remedies laid down in  
Articles 26 and 27, paragraph (3) (Art. 26, 27-3), of the Convention  
has not been complied with by the Applicant;

Whereas, secondly, as regards his complaints concerning his conviction  
and sentence for fraud by the same Court (see IV, (3) of the Facts),  
it is pointed out that, finally, his appeal from the above decision was  
successful in that, on .. November, 1964, the Federal Court quashed his  
conviction by the former court and decided that no further proceedings  
should be taken on this count; whereas, even assuming that his  
allegations in respect of the above proceedings might raise a question  
under the Convention, the alleged maladministration of justice on the  
part of the Regional Court at Hildesheim must be regarded as having  
been remedied by the decision of the Federal Court; whereas it follows  
that this part of the Application is manifestly ill-founded within the  
meaning of Article 27, paragraph (2) (Art. 27-2), of the Convention;

Whereas, in regard to the Applicant's complaints relating to his claim  
for a retrial of the case against him for making false statements and  
the court proceedings concerned (see IV, (4) of the Facts), it is to  
be observed that the Convention, under the terms of Article 1 (Art. 1),  
guarantees only the rights and freedoms set forth in Section I of the  
Convention; and whereas, under Article 25, paragraph (1) (Art. 25-1),  
only the alleged violation of one of those rights and freedoms by a  
Contracting Party can be the subject of an application presented by a  
person, non-governmental organisation or group of individuals;

Whereas otherwise its examination is outside the competence of the  
Commission ratione materiae; whereas the right to a retrial is not as  
such included among the rights and freedoms guaranteed by the  
Convention; and whereas, in accordance with the Commission's constant  
jurisprudence, proceedings concerning applications for retrial fall  
outside the scope of Article 6 (Art. 6) of the Convention (see  
Applications Nos. 864/60 - M v. Austria - Collection of Decisions,  
Volume 9, page 17, and 1237/61 - T. v. Austria - Yearbook V, page 96);  
whereas it follows that this part of the Application is incompatible  
with the provisions of the Convention within the meaning of Article 27,  
paragraph (2) (Art. 27-2), of the Convention;

Whereas, with regard to the Applicant's complaints concerning his  
arrest and detention in Austria (see IV, (5) of the Facts) and his  
alleged bad treatment in prison during his detention in Austria (see  
IV, (7) of the Facts) it is to be observed that the present Application  
is directed solely against the Federal Republic of Germany; whereas his  
above complaints relating to events which have occurred in Austria, can  
in no way be held to involve any responsibility under the Convention  
of the Federal Republic of Germany;  whereas, therefore, the Commission  
has no competence ratione personae to examine these complaints in so  
far as they relate to the Applicant's detention in Austria; whereas it  
follows that, in this respect, the Application is incompatible with the  
provisions of the Convention within the meaning of Article 27,  
paragraph (2) (Art. 27-2), of the Convention;

Whereas, in regard to the Applicant's complaints that he was wrongly  
detained in prison in Germany from .. February, 1963 to .. March, 1963  
following his extradition (see IV, (6) of the Facts) and also in regard  
to his complaints relating to his alleged bad treatment which he  
underwent in prison in Germany (see IV, (7) of the Facts), it is to be  
observed that, under Article 26 (Art. 26) of the Convention, the  
Commission may only deal with a matter after all domestic remedies have  
been exhausted according to the generally recognised rules of  
international law; and whereas the Applicant failed to show that he has  
raised these points before any German Court; whereas, therefore, he has  
not exhausted the remedies available to him under German law;

Whereas, moreover, an examination of the case as it has been submitted,  
including an examination made ex officio, does not disclose the  
existence of any special circumstances which might have absolved the  
Applicant, according to the generally recognised rules of international  
law, from exhausting the domestic remedies at his disposal; whereas,  
therefore, the condition as to the exhaustion of domestic remedies laid  
down in Articles 26 and 27, paragraph (3) (Art. 26, 27-3), of the  
Convention has not been complied with by the Applicant;

Whereas, in regard to the Applicant's complaints that, as a result of  
the forfeiture of his bail, he was deprived of his possessions, and to  
his complaints relating to the court proceedings concerned (see IV, (8)  
of the Facts), it is to be observed that, even assuming that such  
proceedings should fall under Article 6, paragraph (1) (Art. 6-1), of  
the Convention, an examination of the case as it has been submitted,  
including an examination made ex officio, does not disclose any  
appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set forth in the  
Convention or the Protocol and in particular in the Articles of the  
said Protocol;

Whereas it follows that this part of the Application is manifestly  
ill-founded within the meaning of Article 27, paragraph (2)  
(Art. 27-2), of the Convention;

Whereas, in regard to the Applicant's complaints that he suffered  
discriminating treatment by reason of his anti-Nazi opinions (see IV,  
(9) of the Facts), an examination of the case as it has been submitted  
does equally not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights  
and freedoms set forth in the Convention and in particular in Article  
14 (Art. 14); whereas it follows that this part of the Application is  
also manifestly ill-founded within the meaning of Article 27, paragraph  
(2) (Art. 27-2), of the Convention;

Whereas, with regard to the Applicant's complaints relating to the  
length of the proceedings before the Labour Court at Braunschweig  
concerning his claim against the Volkswagenwerke A.G. (see I of the  
Facts), it is to be observed that Article 6, paragraph (1) (Art. 6-1),  
provides that "in the determination of his civil rights and obligations  
... everyone is entitled to a fair and public hearing within a  
reasonable time by an independent and impartial tribunal established  
by law";

Whereas the Applicant alleges that he filed his action in the Labour  
Court of Braunschweig in 1960, where the case is still pending, and,  
after a period of 4 1/2 years, a hearing of the Parties has still not  
yet been fixed; whereas it is pointed out that the right to have one's  
case heard within a reasonable time is, particularly in civil cases,  
dependent on the interested Party taking himself the necessary steps  
duly to pursue the action; whereas, in the present case, the Applicant  
has failed to show in what way he has taken any steps to expedite the  
proceedings before the Labour Court of Braunschweig;

Whereas the Commission is satisfied that an examination of the case as  
it has been submitted, including an examination made ex officio, does  
not disclose any element indicating that it was the Court which was  
responsible for the delay; whereas, consequently, the Commission finds  
no appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set forth in  
the Convention and in particular in Article 6 (Art. 6);

Whereas it follows that this part of the Application is manifestly  
ill-founded within the meaning of Article 27, paragraph (2)  
(Art. 27-2), of the Convention.

Now therefore the Commission declares this Application INADMISSIBLE.

