Sök i Ratio Lex

MAJARIC v. SLOVENIA

3 december 1997 · nr 28400/95 · ECLI:CE:ECHR:1997:1203DEC002840095


Så kom texten hit

  • Källa: Europadomstolen (HUDOC), © ECHR-CEDH · dokumentet i HUDOC
  • Text: domstolens egen text på engelska, utläst ur HUDOC:s HTML. Styckenumren är domens; varje stycke har en egen adress (#p1, #p2 …).
  • Hämtad hit: 13 november 2026
  • Villkor: Domstolens texter återges med källan angiven (© ECHR-CEDH), avgiftsfritt och i informationssyfte, enligt domstolens villkor (echr.coe.int, Copyright and Disclaimer). Den elektroniska versionen ges ut enligt artikel 44.3 i konventionen; den undertecknade texten i domstolens arkiv är den autentiska. Icke-officiella översättningar i HUDOC är skyddade av upphovsrätt och står här bara som länk.

Uppgifter ur HUDOC

Citera

Europakommissionens beslut den 3 december 1997 i målet MAJARIC mot Slovenien (nr 28400/95)

Domstolens text

AS TO THE ADMISSIBILITY OF

Application No. 28400/95
by Ljubo MAJARIC
against Slovenia

The European Commission of Human Rights (First Chamber) sitting
in private on 3 December 1997, the following members being present:

Mrs   J. LIDDY, President
MM    M.P. PELLONPÄÄ
E. BUSUTTIL
A. WEITZEL
C.L. ROZAKIS
L. LOUCAIDES
B. MARXER
B. CONFORTI
N. BRATZA
I. BÉKÉS
G. RESS
A. PERENIC
C. BÎRSAN
K. HERNDL
M. VILA AMIGÓ
Mrs   M. HION
Mr    R. NICOLINI

Mrs   M.F. BUQUICCHIO, Secretary to the Chamber

Having regard to Article 25 of the Convention for the Protection
of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms;

Having regard to the application introduced on 13 December 1994
by Ljubo MAJARIC against Slovenia and registered on 1 September 1995
under file No. 28400/95;

Having regard to:

-    the reports provided for in Rule 47 of the Rules of Procedure of
the Commission;

-    the observations submitted by the respondent Government on
21 June 1996 and the observations in reply submitted by the
applicant on 28 June 1997;

Having deliberated;

Decides as follows:

THE FACTS

The applicant is a Slovenian national born in 1952. He lives in
Nova Gorica. The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may
be summarised as follows.

A.   Particular circumstances of the case

On 6 December 1991 the applicant was charged with sexual assault
on a minor and abduction of minors under Article 103 para. 1 in
conjunction with Article 96 paras. 2 and 3 of the Criminal Code. He was
detained on remand.

On 30 April 1992 the applicant was released from detention on
remand, but was re-detained on 16 June 1992 pursuant to the First
Instance Court`s decision in view of the nature of the offenses and
danger of their repetition.

In the meantime, on 5 June 1992, the applicant's trial opened
before the Nova Gorica First Instance Court, but was adjourned the same
day.

On 28 August a number of victims were heard and on 3 September
1992 the First Instance Court again adjourned the applicant's trial due
to the applicant`s illness.

By decision of the First Instance Court dated 17 September 1992,
the applicant was again released.

On 28 September 1992, the trial should have continued but the
applicant excused himself because of illness. The trial was adjourned
sine die.

On 21 July 1992, the prosecutor lodged a demand for investigation
in relation to another sexual assault on a minor, which had been
discovered in the course of the proceedings. An investigation was open
and an indictment was brought against the applicant on 18 January 1993.
The applicant entered a plea against the indictment which was rejected
on 15 February 1993. On 17 March 1993, the court decided to join the
two proceedings.

On 2 June 1993 the prosecutor requested further investigation on
the ground that there was reasonable suspicion that the applicant had
also criminally neglected and maltreated a minor under Article 96
paras. 1 and 2 of the Criminal Code.

On 21 October 1993 a preliminary charge was filed for these acts
and on 28 March 1995 the court again decided to join these proceedings.

In the period from 18 February 1997 to 14 July 1997 several
hearings were held before the First Instance Court (Okrozno sodisce)
in Nova Gorica, but there has been no first instance judgment to date.

B.   Relevant domestic law

Article 160 of the Constitution of the Republic of Slovenia
provides for the jurisdiction of the Constitutional Court. The
Constitutional Court has jurisdiction, amongst other matters, to
determine complaints of breaches of human rights and fundamental
freedoms by specific acts.

Article 50 of the Constitutional Court Act reads as follows:

"1. Any person may, under the conditions determined by this Act,
lodge a constitutional complaint with the Constitutional Court
if he/she believes that his/her human rights and basic freedoms
have been violated by a specific act of a state body, local
community body or public corporation."

Article 51 of the Constitutional Court Act reads as follows:

"1.   A constitutional complaint may be lodged only after all
remedies have been exhausted.

2.   Before exhaustion of all extraordinary remedies, the
Constitutional Court may exceptionally decide on a constitutional
complaint if the alleged violation is obvious and if the
complainant would suffer irreparable consequences as a result of
the implementation of the individual act."

Articles 72 and 73 of the Law on Courts provide that, in case of
delay of proceedings, any party may address a "supervisory appeal"
(nadzorstvena pritozba) to the president of the court or to the
Ministry of Justice. The president of the court or the Ministry request
the judge dealing with the case to prepare a report as to the state of
the case and to reply to the allegations of the party. The Ministry may
also refer the application to a higher court, which is requested to
examine the functioning of the court and report to the ministry on the
findings.

COMPLAINTS

The applicant complains under Article 6 para. 1 of the Convention
about the length of his criminal proceedings which are still pending
before the first instance. The applicant claims that there were no
hearings from September 1992 until February 1997.

PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE COMMISSION

The application was introduced on 13 December 1994 and registered
on 1 September 1995.

On 12 April 1996 the Commission decided to communicate the
applicant's complaint concerning the length of the criminal proceedings
to the respondent Government and to declare the remainder of the
application inadmissible.

The Government's written observations were submitted on 21 June
1996. The Government`s observations were sent to the applicant for his
observations  to  be  submitted  by 13 August 1996, and again in
January 1997 and April 1997 with an extension of the time-limit until
31 May 1997. The applicant only replied on 28 June 1997.

THE LAW

The applicant complains under Article 6 para. 1 (Art. 6-1) of the
Convention about the length of proceedings which began in December 1991
and are still pending before the first instance court.

Article 6 (Art. 6) of the Convention, insofar as relevant,
provides as follows:

"1.   In the determination of his civil rights and obligations or
of any criminal charge against him, everyone is entitled to a
fair and public hearing within a reasonable time..."

The Government state that the only remedy the applicant had at
his disposal to accelerate the criminal proceedings was the
"supervisory appeal" in accordance with Article 72 of the Law on
Courts. In the case of "supervisory appeal" the president of the court
or the Ministry do not issue any decision, but merely report to the
party on their findings. The Government noted that the applicant filed
such an appeal several times, last on 27 May 1994.

The Government conclude that, in the case of delay of
proceedings, it is not possible to lodge a constitutional complaint.

The applicant claims that his rights are still being violated,
that there is no rule of law in Slovenia and that he is not allowed to
prove his innocence.

The Commission recalls the Convention organs' case-law, according
to which the decisive question in assessing the effectiveness of a
remedy concerning a complaint about the length of proceedings is
whether an applicant can raise this complaint before domestic courts
by claiming specific redress; in other words, whether a remedy exists
that could answer his complaints by providing a direct and speedy, and
not merely indirect, protection of the rights guaranteed in Article 6
para. 1 (Art. 6-1) of the Convention (cf. Eur. Court HR, the Deweer v.
Belgium judgment of 27 February 1980, Series A no. 35, p. 16, para.
29).

The Commission notes that a "supervisory appeal" brought under
Article 72 of the Law on Courts provides no guarantee that proceedings
will be accelerated and results in no obligation on the court
concerned. The Commission finds that the "supervisory appeal" is not
an effective remedy within the meaning of the Convention. The
Government and the applicant concur that it was also not open to the
applicant to file a constitutional complaint with the Constitutional
Court and that there was therefore no effective remedy in this case.
It follows that the present application cannot be declared inadmissible
under Article 26 (Art. 26) of the convention.

As to the length of the applicant`s criminal proceedings, the
Commission considers, in the light of the criteria established by the
case-law of the Convention organs on the question of "reasonable time",
and having regard to all the information in its possession, that an
examination of the merits of the complaint is required.

For these reasons, the Commission, unanimously,

DECLARES THE REMAINDER OF THE APPLICATION ADMISSIBLE, without
prejudging the merits of the case.

M.F. BUQUICCHIO                                 J. LIDDY
Secretary                                    President
to the First Chamber                         of the First Chamber

Målets dokument (4)

  1. Europakommissionens beslut, 12 april 1996 · engelska
  2. Europakommissionens beslut, 3 december 1997 (denna sida) · engelska
  3. Dom, 8 februari 2000 · engelska
  4. Sammanfattning, 8 februari 2000 · engelska